Selinsgrove vs Bethlehem Catholic Football Rivalry

On Friday, Nov. 24, 2017, at Shamokin's Kemp Memorial Stadium, Bethlehem Catholic beat Selinsgrove 33-32 in the Class 4A quarterfinal. The game was tied 26-26 with 4:09 left when Matt Bisko scored from the 3. Logan Leiby found Jarrett Inch for 30 yards with 11 seconds left. The two-point pass to Ricky Cope fell incomplete. Leiby was 13 of 23 for 323 yards and four touchdowns. Inch caught seven passes for 219 yards and all four scores. Selinsgrove finished 11-3.

On Friday, Nov. 17, 2023, at Catasauqua's Alumni Field, Selinsgrove beat Bethlehem Catholic 28-13. Tucker Teats ran 27 times for 223 yards and scored from 36, 71, and 11. Carter Young kicked a 22-yard field goal, and the Seals led 16-13 at the half. Ethan Miller scored from the 2. Carter Vassa caught eight passes for 103 yards and a 5-yard touchdown. The Seals were 12-0-1.